Suggestions for Pizzeria near Brooklyn

Paola G. • June 24, 2015Definitely not your neighborhood pizzeria, but play around with the topping options. The speck is outstanding and the cheese is unreal. Definitely order 2 pies!

Lauren D. • June 16, 2016Best pizzeria in New York. If you've never been, start with the margherita pizza and a special pizza, No. 1 thru No.4 are delicious. If you have 3 or more people order 2 larges at least.

Ben G. • August 22, 2015Great pizza, Brie, garlic, so many good options

Serious Eats • March 29, 2013As much as a labor of love as any pizzeria out there, Paulie Gee's is warm and inviting. It serves wonderful pies patterned on the Neapolitan model but with a local slant.

Polina W. • May 16, 2022Very fun design with board games etc. The Detroit pizzas are delicious and portions are generous. Great for groups as well.

Eater • August 24, 2017Pizza may be the other breakfast of champions, but the real winner is the egg sandwich tucked away at Roberta's Bakery, a few steps down from the famous pizzeria.

Ryan W. • November 6, 2015Absolutely awesome. Great BK pizzeria

Adria C. • March 16, 2018Eat the octopus and the Cauliflower dishes. Outstanding taste in Brooklyn.

Serious Eats • January 20, 2014Solid neighborhood pizzeria with a charming outdoor patio.

León • November 26, 2016La mejor pizza que he probado, súper buena calidad de ingredientes

Chris M. • August 7, 2010Basil pepperoni and portabella. Great balance of flavors

Carmen N. • September 23, 2015Classic pizzeria.

Chloe N. • August 24, 2015Even though Emily is a pizzeria, you should order the burger. It's absolutely divine. I may or may not have heard angels singing when I had my first glorious bite.

Maya B. • September 4, 2016The brunch pizza w lox is AMAZING

Meredith • December 16, 2013Super cozy and delicious. Only pizza on the menu, but it's excellent.

Alex A. • October 20, 2011aside from the squares in the pizzeria, try the philly cheese steak sandwich with garlic bread.

Nihan C. • October 7, 2016Unlike the other pizzerias, a real Italian... Amazing pizza and friendly staff You will definetely love this place

Michael 🍷 E. • September 6, 2015Cheese is great but the pepperoni slice is outstanding; sweet tomato and salty, slightly crispy slices of meaty pepperoni goodness. Do it!

Stephanie • February 13, 2011Probably the best pizzeria in East New York, really affordable too.

Kari R. • April 28, 2013–neighborhood gem indeed! The salads are refreshing and tasty. The service is outstanding: a big yum!

Serious Eats • March 21, 2013One of our favorite pizzerias in NY, Best Pizza churns out wonderful slices from their wood-fired brick oven.

Wayne B. • July 13, 2014Pizzas are very good and so are the bourbon based drinks. Group of 5 ate for $140 + tip

Brad K. • April 24, 2021Claire was amazing and custom-made this mezcal and hibiscus drink that was delicious. The shishito peppers were DELICIOUS, highly recommend (hint: its the umami)

Stephanie W. • June 24, 2022The hellboy is my favorite! The sesame crust is also delicious

Gregory F. • December 5, 2021The porchetta sandwich is pretty good, but beware it’s loaded with whole roasted garlic cloves

David Z. • December 29, 2012So underrated. Just as good as grimaldis without the wait. They are the best "order by the slice" pizzeria in nyc.

Luis S. • December 30, 2014Ótimos pedaços de pizza!

Joslyn H. • July 23, 2023Everything is good, from the perfect pomodoro pasta to the inventive pizzas. Small plates and thoughtful cocktails, a total neighborhood gem.

Ruby A. • February 6, 2023Best sourdough everything bagel 🥯

Jarel H. • May 4, 2021Sausage and sage pizza was fantastic. Great flavor